Personally, I'd prefer the options with decent examples to draw from.

I usually go by the maxim of dice are rolled only if the chance of failure could make the situation more interesting. Dice were rolled and, through meta-gaming, the player unintentionally chose to fail. If it were me GMing, I'd make the situation more interesting. Considering the situation, something should happen to sufficiently give the impression that this was a bad idea. Probably something that still gives them an opportunity to fix what they broke, or the campaign will go off in an unforeseen direction and that's an option as well.

This comes up enough times in one campaign I'm in, that this would be completely normal to me. For instance, while retrieving some treasure from some ancient pyramids, we woke up the not-Necrons that were dormant inside. They'll probably be back to harass us in the not too distant future. 

I agree, with the caveat that a player with 3 heritages (etc) should really have to explain how they got that third one, given that they have only 2 parents.  Paladin obviously has that explanation built in.

Heritage implies a lineage going back farther than one's immediate parents (ie: grandparents, ancestors, etc.) which would branch exponentially.

My group has taken to stacking Species Feats to simulate oddball things like Gorgons and Mariliths and Kobolds and such, rather than merely craft something from scratch. All a matter of taste and imagination at the end of the day.

(and ain't that a stupid fucking name for a third iteration?)

I take it as a lame pun for their miscast opinions on the console wars. In a similar vein, the Wii U sounds like a child imitating an ambulance. That brings me boundless amusement.

Class.. if you would open your book to page 386.  And solve for Z.  Where Z is the is hilariousness.

(D20)12 + [(4+1+2+3+4+2+1)] = Z  (12 and a Ruinous)  <-- they slapped him down because it was the same story he used for a previous character.
(D20)20 + [(3+2+1+1+1+1+1)] = Z  (20 and a Castrophic)  <-- Rolled the 20 and purposefully chose to ask everyone to give him a 1.

And a quick question.  "GM may introduce any 1 NPC type or quality" ...do those stack?  Like.. if I spend enough action dice, can I make a Fairy / Beast / Infernal Burrower?  cause.. umm.. I'd REALLY like to for this character...

Considering the language of the thing, I don't see why not. It'd take a while, but I'd say sure. Also, I don't blame the person for asking for the Catastrophic on that one. I'd do that myself, but hey, I'm a sadist when it comes to my characters. I like to see them suffer. 

Any attempt to bring more people to the hobby, especially little people with big imaginations, is an A+ in my book.

The Alchemist would be a Keeper with the Alchemy Feat chain. Until Spellbound comes out the Witch and the Summoner would be a bit trickier. If it were me, I'd go Mage with a Personal Lieutenant for the Summoner. Back that up with other Summon Stuff spells.

Any illustrators or painters?  Or aspiring illustrators or painters?  This looks neat:  NeoLucida - A Portable Camera Lucida for the 21st Century

I actually have use for one of those. Woot!

I've had a game where every option looked impossible (and nearly all of them were, not that we could tell the difference) that only lasted a day because of it. On the other hand, some of us will routinely take the 'bad' option because things get more interesting. =/

Pretty sure that's how I ended up married...

Do I want to know how that happened?

As long as it didn't involve two wallabies and a midget, I think we're good.

...and if it does...?

You clearly have the more interesting Saturday nights. I'm allergic to macropodidae.

Pretty sure that's how I ended up married...

Do I want to know how that happened?

As long as it didn't involve two wallabies and a midget, I think we're good.

Creative minds and idle hands are a dangerous thing indeed. 

Hmmm... this is an interesting concept. To add fuel to this thread, have you considered bamboo, wood or (to play on the anti-fey/ghost aspect) cold iron?

Survivor blasting Eye of the Tiger?

Mickey: I didn't hear no bell, Pat. I didn't hear no bell!

That just leaves you with necromancy, because the cake is a lie. 

And vanilla cupcakes are little white lies!

Fear not, this was my feeble attempt at a LOTR movie joke. All remains as well as it can be in Spellboundia.

One does not simply walk into Spellbound...

  If that can't keep someone's spirits up and motivated, I don't know what will!

Cake! And some necromantic rituals.