Crafty Games Forum

Community => License to Improvise => Topic started by: paddyfool on July 11, 2011, 05:52:42 AM

Title: "I can fly" feat and specialty
Post by: paddyfool on July 11, 2011, 05:52:42 AM
Returning to an old idea (http://www.crafty-games.com/forum/index.php?topic=4992.msg94021#msg94021) here: spellcasters who come up with or whom are granted new powers on the fly are something of a staple of the genre.  How about a feat to represent that?

I can fly
When new powers come to you, they may be a surprise to everyone, yourself included
Prerequisites Player character only
Benefit: You don't have to choose spells learned immediately when you gain ranks in spellcasting. Instead, you may ‘reveal’ your spells at any time during play.  The first time you cast a spell which you have just revealed, however, your error rate increases by 2.  All unrevealed spells must be revealed before you gain your next level.

Savant (specialty)
You live and breathe magic.  Sometimes this means that people around you get burned.
Bonus feat: I can fly (1 point)
Attribute training: The lower of your Wisdom and Charisma increases by 1 (1 point)
Nothing up my Sleeve: You may make Spellcasting checks as if you have a mage's pouch. (1 point)
Practiced Resolve: If you spend an AD to boost a resolve check and still fail, you may get it back. (2 points)
Unbreakable: Each time you suffer attribute impairment, it decreases by 1 (min 0) (1 point)
More than luck: Your starting AD increases by 1 (3 points)

EDIT: Morgenstern's better version

I can Fly
You always have the perfect trick up your sleeve.
Prerequisites: Spellcasting 1+
Benefit: Once per adventure as a free action you may choose a spell. You are considered to know that spell until the end of the current adventure.
Special: This feat may not be taken as a temporary feat.
Title: Re: "I can fly" feat and specialty
Post by: glimmerrat on July 11, 2011, 08:58:40 AM
I can fly
When new powers come to you, they may be a surprise to everyone, yourself included
Prerequisites Player character only
Benefit: You don't have to choose spells learned immediately when you gain ranks in spellcasting. Instead, you may ‘reveal’ your spells at any time during play.  The first time you cast a spell which you have just revealed, however, your error rate increases by 2.  All unrevealed spells must be revealed before you gain your next level.

This sucks.



I'm just kidding. This is actually an incredibly cool idea. I like it!  ;)
Title: Re: "I can fly" feat and specialty
Post by: aegis on July 11, 2011, 09:13:19 AM
I can fly.
'love it!   ;D
Savant (specialty)
Ouch! I know it follows Origin creation rules, but it is abusively amazingly good. Yeah, powerful feat, bonus to one of two main Mage attributes, spellcasting without kit (which should definitely be defined as a 1.5-points-worth ability at least), impairement resistance, plus 1 additional SAD! Waaaay too cool a combination in my opinion. By that I mean, given the choice, I wouldn't even consider any other Specialty for a spellcaster.  ::)
Title: Re: "I can fly" feat and specialty
Post by: paddyfool on July 11, 2011, 09:29:38 AM
I had been a bit worried that Savant might be too much, particularly with the Attribute training.  Perhaps if that and "Nothing up my sleeve" were swapped out for Practiced Resolve (to represent a very focused mind)...

As for "I can fly", I've since thought of one bit of slightly scary, if not quite problematic, synergy: what if someone took both that and "I can swim"?  It seems like you could end up with a Mage who'd practically never face a hurdle he'd be unequipped for.  This would be very fitting for various flavours of genius, however...
Title: Re: "I can fly" feat and specialty
Post by: Morgenstern on July 11, 2011, 11:35:47 AM
+1 SAD was 4 points, and I believe it still should be :).

You may want to add come text to I can fly for what it does if you have no unspent spellslots, so it doesn't eventually become a dead feat.
Title: Re: "I can fly" feat and specialty
Post by: spinningdice on July 11, 2011, 01:44:14 PM
Can you not nearly do it with I Can Swim anyway, spells known = Spellcasting ranks + Wisdom score, thereby if you hold back some skill points you can drop them into Spellcasting to learn new spells on the fly?
Of course that does leave you suboptimal until you use them, but the very nature of the feats in question does that anyway.
Title: Re: "I can fly" feat and specialty
Post by: Gentry on July 11, 2011, 01:50:09 PM
Is there ultimately a problem with keeping spell slots in reserve to begin with? Or is this notion more about being able to spontaneously fill an unspent spell slot?
Title: Re: "I can fly" feat and specialty
Post by: The_Grand_User on July 11, 2011, 04:31:48 PM
Some GMs might even require you do that.
Title: Re: "I can fly" feat and specialty
Post by: paddyfool on July 11, 2011, 04:59:10 PM
Can you not nearly do it with I Can Swim anyway, spells known = Spellcasting ranks + Wisdom score, thereby if you hold back some skill points you can drop them into Spellcasting to learn new spells on the fly?
Of course that does leave you suboptimal until you use them, but the very nature of the feats in question does that anyway.

That's an interesting rules exploit... hmm.  Maybe.  Drat.

Is there ultimately a problem with keeping spell slots in reserve to begin with? Or is this notion more about being able to spontaneously fill an unspent spell slot?

The latter.  So, you suddenly need to turn invisible: bang! You have that power.  Only once per level, generally speaking, but that's still worth a great deal.
Title: Re: "I can fly" feat and specialty
Post by: Morgenstern on July 11, 2011, 11:59:31 PM
Once you said "once per level" it clicked - make it into an extra spell slot.

I can Fly
You always have the perfect trick up your sleeve.
Prerequisites: Spellcasting 1+
Benefit: Once per adventure as a free action you may choose a spell. You are considered to know that spell until the end of the current adventure.
Special: This feat may not be taken as a temporary feat.
Title: Re: "I can fly" feat and specialty
Post by: paddyfool on July 12, 2011, 12:40:39 AM
My word, that's elegant.  I bow to the master.
Title: Re: "I can fly" feat and specialty
Post by: Catodon on July 12, 2011, 01:48:48 AM
Yoink!
Title: Re: "I can fly" feat and specialty
Post by: Deral on July 12, 2011, 04:42:39 AM
My god it's so simple it's genius.

Really, I'm quite impressed at how that's both an excellent solution and one that completely didn't cross my mind, even though it uses a very common MC mechanic.
Title: Re: "I can fly" feat and specialty
Post by: Lifer4700 on September 07, 2013, 05:57:13 AM
*yoink!*